Preliminary Issue Trial Opening in NFU Mutual Group Action
10 November
Case Name:
- South Farm Ltd & Others and
- Innventure Ltd & Others v. NFU Mutual
Court:
- High Court of Justice, Business and Property Courts (Commercial Court)
Date:
- Tuesday, 10 November 2026
Time:
- Afternoon Session (Typically 2:00 PM)
Location:
- Expected to be The Rolls Building, Fetter Lane, London
Event Summary
This hearing marks the start of the substantive oral arguments in the Preliminary Issue Trial against NFU Mutual. After 1.5 days of judicial pre-reading (beginning Monday, 9 November), the court will sit to determine critical legal questions regarding COVID-19 business interruption claims.
Why This is Significant
-
Systemic Importance: This is one of the largest group actions against a single insurer, representing over 100 venues (hospitality and farming businesses).
-
Key Issues: The court will decide if NFU Mutual’s policy wordings—specifically the definition of an “incident”—cover the 2020 lockdowns. It will also address the AICOW (Additional Increased Cost of Working) provisions, which could significantly increase the insurer’s total financial exposure.
-
Long-Awaited: Policyholders have been seeking remedies for over half a decade; this trial follows a critical Case Management Conference held in December 2025 that joined the two largest claim groups together.
Schedule at a Glance
| Date | Phase | Detail |
| Mon, 9 Nov | Judicial Reading | Court not in session; Judge reviewing evidence. |
| Tue, 10 Nov (AM) | Judicial Reading | Final pre-reading for the Bench. |
| Tue, 10 Nov (PM) | Opening Day | Substantive hearing commences. |
| 11 – 13 Nov | Oral Arguments | Evidence and legal submissions continue. |
